| Score | Publication | Review | Copy |
| 91+ | View from the Cellar | The “Montana” Vendimia Seleccionada bottling from Legado del Moncayo hails from vineyards growing up the side of the volcano, with the vines ranging from forty to sixty years of age now. Unlike the regular bottling, the Montana is raised in used French casks for eight months prior to bottling. The wine offers up a wilder personality, from the combination of the older vines and the higher elevation, with the 2019 delivering scents of dark berries, spit-roasted game, pepper, garrigue, stony minerality, bonfire and a touch of celery seed in the upper register. On the palate the wine is deep, full and very nicely balanced, with a good core, ripe tannins, lovely focus and grip and a long, complex and still light on its feet finish. This has a bit broader shoulders than the regular bottling, as well as just a bit more tannin, but it shares the same exceptional value, as this excellent bottle of Garnacha retails in the US for $15 a bottle! 2023-2040. John Gilman - Issue #91 / February 2021 |
|
| 91 | Wine Review Online | I’ve never tasted a vintage of this special, upper elevation selection from
Legado del Moncayo that I didn’t love, and the 2019 keeps that string alive. Always darker, deeper, and slightly plusher in feel than the (freshly delicious) regular bottling, it nevertheless remains quite lithe and lovely. There are, as usual, some black cherry notes in this bottling to go along with the red ones, and the overall proportions of fruit sweetness, acidity and tannin are just right. I’ve placed this on the wine list of all the restaurants for which I consult in multiple vintages, and the 2019 is a very strong candidate indeed. Michael Franz – Issue: December 1, 2020 |
| Score | Publication | Review | Copy |
| 90+ | View from the Cellar | The 2020 vintage of “Montaña” Vendimia Seleccionada bottling from Legado del Moncayo hails from vineyards growing up the side of the volcano, with the vines between forty to sixty years of age. The Montaña is raised in used French casks for eight months prior to bottling and the 2020 version is a touch riper than the regular bottling, coming in at 14.5 percent alcohol this year. The wine is deeper on the nose from the older vines, offering up scents of dark berries, spit-roasted venison, dark soil tones, coffee bean, a hint of the autumnal shadings to come with bottle age, woodsmoke and garrigue. On the palate the wine is deep, ripe, full-bodied and chewy, with an excellent core of fruit, fine soil inflection, firm tannins and a long, complex and promising finish. There is just a whisper of backend heat here, but overall the wine is nicely balanced and will be a fine drink once it softens up a bit. Unlike the regular bottling from Legado del Moncayo, this old vine cuvée will demand a bit of time in the cellar before it drinks with generosity. 2027-2050+. John Gilman – Issue #98 March/April 2022 |
|
| 88 | Wine Spectator | Fresh and balanced, this shows notes of ripe, candied raspberry and blueberry fruit. Offers light, taut tannis, with violet and spice accents. Drink now. 6,000 cases made, 5,000 cases imported. Alison Napjus - April 2024 |
| Score | Publication | Review | Copy |
| 92 | OwenBargreen.com | 2021 Legado Del Moncayo ‘Vendima Seleccionada’ Garnacha- The seriously good 2021 Legado Del Moncayo ‘Vendima Seleccionada’ Garnacha comes from 40-60 year old bush vines set at 700-750 meters. Showing off its dark core, this delivers good depth and concentration with smoked meats, kumquat rind and dense red fruits with salty minerals and brilliant tension on the palate. A killer buy at under 20 dollars USD, enjoy now and over the next few years. Drink 2024-2032- Owen Bargreen - November 18, 2024 |
|
| 91 | View from the Cellar | The 2021 Garnacha “Montaña” from Legado Del Moncayo is their older vine selection, with the vines ranging from forty to more than sixty years of age, and growing on the sides of the extinct volcano about which these vineyards are planted. The wine is aged in older oak casks, rather than tank. The wine is the same ripeness as the regular bottling, but shows a bit deeper color because of its oak elevage. The bouquet wafts from the glass in a mix of black raspberries, grilled meats, woodsmoke, garrigue, dark soil tones and a gentle touch of cedary oak. On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied and nicely structured, with excellent depth at the core, firm, buried tannins, excellent focus and grip and a long, nascently complex and most impressive finish. This will need a few more years’ worth of bottle age before it starts to drink, but it is a step up in seriousness and an outstanding bargain. 2031-2065. John Gilman - Issue #103 January/February 2023. |
| Score | Publication | Review | Copy |
| 92 | Wine Review Online | This wine is consistently among the finest values of any wine I taste that’s priced under $20, and during multiple past vintages it has won its way into a restaurant group selection program by coming out on top in a blind tasting of top competitors — a tasting for which I select the wines but do not vote. As in past years, it shows good concentration and very notable depth of flavor, but without any of the heaviness that can mark some wines grown at lower elevations in the Garnacha-intensive appellations of Aragón. On the contrary, this vintage (like many before it) shows a Pinot-like softness with more flavor than seems possible based on its rather modest physical weight. The red and black fruit flavors have an open, easy character to them without seeming at all overtly fruity — much less “grapey.” Enduringly enjoyable to drink and highly versatile with food, this can also be sipped on its own with great pleasure. . Michael Franz; September 24,2025 |
|
| 92 | OwenBargreen.com | Another really good edition of this wine, the 2023 Legado Del Moncayo ‘Vendima Seleccionada’ Garnacha comes from 40-60 year old bush vines set at 700-750 meters. A steal at this price, this offers concentrated red fruits, with smoky and salty nuances, with Satsuma orange zest and damp, rocky soils. Drink 2025-2032. Owen Bargreen- December 4, 2025 |
